Selecting the right general contractor (GC) can sometimes feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. With so many options out there, how do you sift through the noise and find someone who won’t turn your dream project into a waking nightmare? Fear not—we’re here to help you decode the madness of the GC selection process.  

Whether you’re an owner, a construction manager, a retailer, or a developer, the stakes are high. Late timelines, ballooning budgets, and subpar quality aren’t just nightmares—they’re business risks. The good news is, the right GC can make those nightmares disappear. The bad news? You’ve got to know what you’re looking for.  

Here are the top five qualities to keep an eye on, along with some insider insights into how an outdated industry sometimes gets it hilariously (or heartbreakingly) wrong.  

‍

1. Communication Skills: Straight Talk, No Jargon  

You’d think good communication would be a baseline expectation when trusting someone with your multi-million-dollar project, right? Well, welcome to the construction world, where vague updates and confusing jargon somehow became an art form.  

Here’s the deal—a great GC isn’t just a builder; they’re a communicator. They need to keep you in the loop without drowning you in unnecessary technical details. Schedules, budgets, changes—they should all be delivered clearly and professionally. And when things inevitably go sideways (because they will), the best GCs own it, talk you through it, and work collaboratively to find solutions.  

Red flag alert: If your potential GC keeps dodging questions or overloading you with buzzwords, run. They either don’t know what’s happening, or worse, they don’t want you to know.  

Why it matters: A report by the Project Management Institute found that poor communication is responsible for 56% of project failures. Don’t become part of that statistic.  

‍

2. Track Record of Reliability  

What’s the difference between a reliable GC and one who ghosts you the second things get tough? A paper trail of successful projects—and no, we’re not talking about the ones that "technically" finished on time because the GC padded the schedule.  

A proven track record is your GC’s resume. Ask for references, photos, or even site visits to see their previous work. Check how they handle tight deadlines, weather delays, or surprise inspections. A good GC has systems in place to manage chaos—and trust us, there will be chaos.  

Pro tip: Google reviews aren’t enough. Talk to former clients directly and ask the tough questions. Were budgets respected? Were punch lists handled quickly? Did the GC vanish faster than a magician when payment neared?  

Why it matters: Time equals money in construction. A GC that’s consistently on schedule is saving you both.  

‍

3. Problem-Solving Ability (a.k.a. Creativity Under Fire)  

If construction were predictable, we wouldn’t need GCs—we’d just buy kits and assemble office buildings like IKEA furniture. (Come to think of it, that might be faster than some build timelines, but we digress.)  

The best GCs are creative problem-solvers who thrive under pressure. Whether it’s dealing with site constraints, last-minute design changes, or a surprise discovery during excavation (yes, unearthed Civil War cannonballs are an actual thing), they stay calm and find workable solutions.  

To test for this, ask point-blank during the interview process, “What’s the toughest problem you’ve faced on a project, and how did you solve it?” A deer-in-headlights look is your cue to move on.  

Why it matters: Every project has curveballs. A GC without creative problem-solving skills is like a ship captain without a rudder—you’re destined to end up underwater.  

‍

4. Commitment to Quality  

Raise your hand if you’ve seen a brand-new building with cracked drywall or uneven finishes—because we sure have. Quality isn’t just about aesthetics; it’s about durability and functionality. Do it wrong, and you’ll be budgeting for repairs before the ribbon-cutting ceremony.  

A top-notch GC is obsessed with quality control. They vet their subcontractors rigorously and won’t accept work that doesn’t meet the standard. They also know the latest building codes, energy efficiency standards, and material innovations like the back of their hand.  

Inside scoop: The construction industry has a bad habit of cutting corners to save costs, but those “savings” often cost more in the long run. A GC with integrity won’t play that game—and that’s exactly the kind you want.  

Why it matters: A sturdy, well-built project reflects your brand. Subpar construction? That reflects poorly on everyone involved.  

‍

5. Financial Transparency and Budget Management

Hands up if you’ve dealt with surprise charges magically appearing on an invoice? “Oh, you wanted that included in the bid? Silly us!” Construction budgeting is riddled with black holes where money mysteriously vanishes. That’s why it’s critical to work with a GC who’s financially transparent from the start.  

The right GC provides detailed line-item budgets and sticks to them. They communicate cost changes immediately and ensure no hidden fees sneak up later. Oh, and they won’t ask for hefty upfront payments—you know, just to ensure “cash flow” (translation: fund their other projects).  

Red flag alert: If your prospective GC is evasive about cost breakdowns or insists on lump sums instead of detailed estimates, treat that like a flashing neon warning sign.  

Why it matters: Budget overruns not only derail your project but could also damage your reputation if they become public knowledge.  

‍

Closing the Deal

By now, you probably realize that selecting a GC is a lot like dating. You’ll meet some smooth talkers, a fair share of disasters, and maybe even a few that ghost you after the first meeting. But when you find “The One,” it’s worth the time and effort.  

If you’re ready to take the guesswork out of finding the perfect partner for your project, we can help. At Outbidd, we’ve built a better way to manage the entire RFP process, from handling RFIs and organizing documents to analyzing bids effectively. Our platform ensures you ask the right questions and evaluate bids thoroughly, so you can confidently select the best partner for your project.

‍

Book a demo today at outbidd.com or reach out to us at hey@outbidd.com. Because your project deserves more than outdated industry practices—it deserves smooth sailing from start to finish.